📝 AITAH for not giving my sister my second phone for free?

By Swiftkiller329 • Score: 1 • April 22, 2025 6:13 PM


To preface, it’s an IPhone 8. I’ve had it since 2020 and it’s in pretty alright condition besides the cracked and some overheating (Tbf I’ve had it since I was 15 lol). It was my previous phone before my current IPhone 11 Pro.

My sister broke two of her phones somehow, idek how cuz I don’t live with my family anymore, I saw her broken phones (I think one is an iPhone 12 and the other is an iPhone 8 Pro) in her room, which was previously my room before moving out. She uses other devices like the house computer and IPad for my younger siblings a lot more now that she has no phone.

Anyways it started on Sunday when I visited them and was talking to my siblings and mum, after I was done she came up to me and asked for my second phone. I told her I would give it to her, but not for free obviously. She said I’m being selfish and that she’s just borrowing it. She has two broken phones keep in mind. I leave and return on Tuesday, she asks me for it a second time. I tell her the same thing I told her the other day and she’s laughing at me for asking for money for MY second phone (which actually works well, compared to her shattered phones lol) so I dismiss it and move on.

Am I wrong for acting like this? I just wanted to verify what I think.

View on Reddit